When a Publishing Opportunity Turned Out to Be a Scam
Updated: 14 minutes ago

On November 6, 2026, I received a message through the contact form on my Contact page. The sender claimed to be a Senior Editor at Grand Central Publishing, an imprint of Hachette Book Group. They had supposedly come across Sammy Specific #1: Taking It Literally, and expressed interest in a potential publishing opportunity.
It mentioned characters and elements of the story. It asked whether I had literary representation and whether I had other children's or middle-grade projects. The sender acknowledged that they hadn't read the book in its entirety, while suggesting that its premise had caught their attention.
The message was personalized enough to make me believe that someone had taken an interest in what I had created. For someone who has spent years trying to get his work published, you can probably imagine how exciting that message was. I was excited. I was hopeful. I thought that perhaps, after all this time, someone in the publishing industry had finally noticed my work. And then I discovered the truth.
The inquiry was a scam.
The person who contacted me had falsely claimed to represent a legitimate publishing company. The identity they used belonged to a real publishing professional, but the inquiry itself was not legitimate. Below is the original message I received through my website's contact form. The impersonated individual's name is redacted:
Hello Tyler,
I hope you're having a great week.
Am I speaking with Tyler Naimoli?
My name is [REDACTED], and I serve as a Senior Editor at Grand Central Publishing. My role involves working with authors and evaluating projects with distinctive voices, compelling storytelling, and strong potential to connect with readers.
I recently came across *Sammy Specific #1: Taking It Literally* and wanted to introduce myself. I have not read the book in full at this stage. Given the demands of my editorial schedule, I initially reviewed the premise and publicly available information surrounding the project, and what I saw was compelling enough to make me interested in learning more.
What particularly caught my attention was the delightful setup of five-year-old Sammy taking every phrase in his world completely literally. The resulting spectrum of reactions—ranging from humorous everyday misunderstandings to neighborhood-wide chaos—creates a wonderfully engaging core dynamic. Balancing his friendships with Daniel and Sarah alongside rivalries with Larry Literal and the Tyranno-Bully gives the story a rich community feel. Ultimately, it highlights a warm, underlying message: despite the chaos, life in the neighborhood simply wouldn't be the same without Sammy's unique perspective.
The combination of literal-minded humor and a relatable, vibrant neighborhood dynamic suggests a project with an interesting point of view and potential to connect with its intended readership. I was especially interested in the comedic rivalry between Sammy Specific and Larry Literal, which prompted me to reach out directly.
Could you let me know whether you are currently represented by a literary agent? If you are, I would be happy for any further discussion to proceed through your representation. If you are not represented and remain interested in exploring a potential publishing opportunity, I would be glad to hear from you.
Any potential publishing consideration would, of course, remain subject to a full editorial assessment and review of the appropriate material.
I would also be interested to know whether you are currently developing another manuscript or continuing to work in the area of children's middle grade & chapter books. If so, I would be glad to learn a little more about what you are working toward.
If this is of interest, I would be delighted to hear from you.
Keep being wonderful,
[REDACTED]
Senior Editor
Grand Central Publishing
IMPORTANT NOTICE
Grand Central Publishing will never request payment or banking information. If you receive any communication claiming to represent Grand Central Publishing that requests money, please verify its authenticity before responding.
On November 9, I contacted Hachette Book Group directly through its official fraud-reporting channel about the message. A representative confirmed in writing that the message was fraudulent and explained that scammers have been impersonating Hachette employees and making fraudulent publishing offers to authors. They also said that the information in the message would be forwarded to its legal and IT departments. I also preserved the original notification email in its EML format, allowing the original email data and technical headers to accompany my reports to the organizations reviewing the incident.

I wasn't content to simply delete the message and move on. In addition to reporting the incident to Hachette, I submitted reports to the FTC and FBI IC3, and contacted Wix because the fraudulent message had been submitted through my website's contact form. Wix subsequently requested the original notification email, its technical headers, the complete form submission, and Hachette's written confirmation so that it could forward the documentation for internal assessment.
After several exchanges with Wix Customer Care, a representative confirmed that my report had reached the company's specialized security team and that the team was actively working on it. I have not yet received confirmation of the outcome of that review, but I appreciate knowing that the incident has reached the appropriate team.
I also contacted Writer Beware, an organization dedicated to documenting publishing scams and warning writers. Its representative acknowledged my report, and I appreciate the organization's work maintaining resources that help authors recognize impersonation schemes and protect themselves from fraudulent publishing offers.

I cannot tell you the identity or location of the perpetrator. I don't know what they hoped to gain from contacting me, and I won't pretend to know their motivations. But I do know that impersonating a publishing professional to exploit an author's hopes is a particularly cruel way to deceive someone. And I can tell you how it made me feel.
I've spent years creating children's books, comic strips, graphic novels, and other projects that I genuinely believe deserve to find their readers. I've also spent years pursuing legitimate publishing opportunities, so when someone contacted me claiming to be interested in my work, I was thrilled. I wanted to believe it was finally happening. And that's what made the deception so upsetting.
My excitement was genuine. The publishing opportunity wasn't.
I am grateful that these organizations have taken the time to receive and review my reports. I did not lose money, provide financial information, send a manuscript, or enter into a fraudulent publishing agreement. I'm fortunate in that respect. But the absence of financial loss doesn't mean this experience didn't hurt.
This experience has prompted me to make a couple of important changes to this website. On the Contact page, I've added reCAPTCHA protection to my contact form to help reduce automated spam submissions. I've also added a new section titled "Publishing & Professional Inquiries" that outlines the precautions I take when evaluating unsolicited professional communications.
The notice explains that I welcome legitimate inquiries from literary agents, publishers, editors, and other publishing professionals, but that I independently verify the identities and professional affiliations of anyone claiming to represent an organization. It also establishes some important boundaries: I will not pay unsolicited individuals to review my manuscripts or secure publishing agreements. I will not provide financial information or sign agreements based solely on unsolicited communications. I will, however, report fraudulent inquiries to the FBI, FTC, Wix, Writer Beware, and any impersonated publishers or individuals, as I did with this case.

I want legitimate publishing professionals to know that I'm still very much interested in hearing from them. At the same time, I want to ensure that future opportunities are genuine and that my work is approached through legitimate professional channels. I hope these precautions will help protect both my creative work and the opportunities I've spent years pursuing.
To everyone who has supported my creative work, thank you. And to legitimate publishers, editors, and literary agents who might be reading this: I hope you'll take a look at what I've created. There's a whole universe of stories waiting to find its audience, and I'd really like to give it that opportunity.
Stay enlightened, educated and entertained, folks.






